Comrade:ComradeSyntrofos/sandbox/Debunking myths: Difference between revisions

m (CriticalResist moved page Comrade:SouvlakiTechGr/sandbox/Debunking myths to Comrade:ComradeSyntrofos/sandbox/Debunking myths: Automatically moved page while renaming the user "SouvlakiTechGr" to "ComradeSyntrofos")
mNo edit summary
Tag: Visual edit
 
(3 intermediate revisions by the same user not shown)
Line 1: Line 1:
Here I'll cite sources to debunk common anti-communist and other myths. Of course, if I find more material, I'll add it here.
Here I'll cite sources to debunk common anti-communist and other myths. Of course, if I find more material, I'll add it here.
Titles with an asterisk are not finished.


== Anti-communist myths ==
== Anti-communist myths ==


=== Soviet Union / Warsaw Pact ===
=== Soviet Union / Warsaw Pact* ===


==== Myth 1: "The Soviet Union manufactured a famine in Ukraine" ====
==== Myth 1: "The Soviet Union manufactured a famine in Ukraine" ====
Line 33: Line 35:
* RESOURCE 3: ''[http://gen.lib.rus.ec/book/index.php?md5=3043d96567ceab152a0992313bcf82b9 Socialism Betrayed]'' by Keeran and Kenny
* RESOURCE 3: ''[http://gen.lib.rus.ec/book/index.php?md5=3043d96567ceab152a0992313bcf82b9 Socialism Betrayed]'' by Keeran and Kenny
* RESOURCE 4: ''[http://gen.lib.rus.ec/book/index.php?md5=bcb105833aa3f469f1131209e3875a9f Life and Terror in Stalin's Russia, 1934–1941]'' by Robert Thurston
* RESOURCE 4: ''[http://gen.lib.rus.ec/book/index.php?md5=bcb105833aa3f469f1131209e3875a9f Life and Terror in Stalin's Russia, 1934–1941]'' by Robert Thurston
* RESOURCE 5: ''[https://gowans.wordpress.com/2009/10/25/democracy-east-germany-and-the-berlin-wall/ Democracy, East Germany, and the Berlin Wall]'' by Stephen Gowans
* RESOURCE 5: ''[https://archive.org/details/TheRussiansAreComing The Russians are Coming: The Politics of Anti-Sovietism]'' by V.L. Allen
* RESOURCE 6: ''[https://archive.org/details/TheRussiansAreComing The Russians are Coming: The Politics of Anti-Sovietism]'' by V.L. Allen
* RESOURCE 6: ''[https://www.marxists.org/reference/archive/stalin/works/1936/12/05.htm The 1936 Soviet Constitution]''
* RESOURCE 7: ''[https://www.marxists.org/reference/archive/stalin/works/1936/12/05.htm The 1936 Soviet Constitution]''
* RESOURCE 7: ''[http://gen.lib.rus.ec/book/index.php?md5=c22e40075143d321a449a15690f82720 Soviet Democracy]'' by Pat Sloan
* RESOURCE 8: ''[http://gen.lib.rus.ec/book/index.php?md5=c22e40075143d321a449a15690f82720 Soviet Democracy]'' by Pat Sloan
 
==== Myth 4: "Lenin actually wanted to be succeeded in Trotsky, not Stalin"* ====
(TO BE STARTED)
 
==== Myth 5: "The Nazis and the Soviets were the same and were allies"* ====
(TO BE STARTED)
 
==== Myth 6: "Stalin was an anti-semite"* ====
(TO BE STARTED)
 
==== Myth 7: "Beria was a pedophile"* ====
(TO BE STARTED)
 
==== Myth 8: "The 1921-1922 famine was manufactured by the Soviet Union"* ====
(TO BE STARTED)
 
==== Myth 9: "The 1956 Hungarian Revolution was a democratic revolution against the communists and was brutally repressed by the Soviet Union"* ====
(TO BE STARTED)


=== People's Republic of China ===
==== Myth 10: "The Prague Spring was a democratic revolution against the communists and was brutally repressed by the Soviet Union"* ====
(TO BE STARTED)
 
==== Myth 11: "Stalin wanted a divided Germany"* ====
(TO BE STARTED)
 
==== Myth 12: "East Germany was a totalitarian dictatorship which killed everyone who tried to leave and was also poor"* ====
 
* RESOURCE 1: ''[https://gowans.wordpress.com/2009/10/25/democracy-east-germany-and-the-berlin-wall/ Democracy, East Germany, and the Berlin Wall]'' by Stephen Gowans\
 
==== Myth 13: "Stalin wanted to control Yugoslavia"* ====
(TO BE STARTED)
 
=== People's Republic of China* ===


==== Myth 1: "Mao killed ~78 million people" ====
==== Myth 1: "Mao killed ~78 million people" ====
Line 55: Line 87:
* RESOURCE 4: ''[http://gen.lib.rus.ec/book/index.php?md5=69633412b4947eb197779d652ba6e331 Shenfan: The Continuing Revolution in a Chinese Village]'' by William Hinton
* RESOURCE 4: ''[http://gen.lib.rus.ec/book/index.php?md5=69633412b4947eb197779d652ba6e331 Shenfan: The Continuing Revolution in a Chinese Village]'' by William Hinton


==== Myth 3: "China has reverted to capitalism" (unfinished) ====
==== Myth 3: "China has reverted to capitalism"* ====


* RESOURCE 1: ''[[Essay:Why China is not Capitalist|Why China is not Capitalist]]'' by ProleWiki user and PRC citizen GojiraTheWumao  
* RESOURCE 1: ''[[Essay:Why China is not Capitalist|Why China is not Capitalist]]'' by ProleWiki user and PRC citizen GojiraTheWumao  


==== Myth 4: "China is a totalitarian dictatorship" (unfinished) ====
==== Myth 4: "China is a totalitarian dictatorship"* ====


* RESOURCE 1: ''[https://english.www.gov.cn/archive/lawsregulations/201911/20/content_WS5ed8856ec6d0b3f0e9499913.html Constitution of the People's Republic of China]''
* RESOURCE 1: ''[https://english.www.gov.cn/archive/lawsregulations/201911/20/content_WS5ed8856ec6d0b3f0e9499913.html Constitution of the People's Republic of China]''
* RESOURCE 2: ''[https://undocs.org/pdf?symbol=en/A/HRC/41/G/17 UN resolution on Global South countries]''
==== Myth 5: "China commits a genocide against Uyghurs"* ====
* RESOURCE 1: ''[https://www.worldbank.org/en/news/statement/2019/11/11/world-bank-statement-on-review-of-project-in-xinjiang-china World Bank investigation of Xinjiang]''
* RESOURCE 2: ''[https://www.oic-oci.org/docdown/?docID=4447&refID=1250 Organization of Islamic Cooperation investigation of Xinjiang (document 1)]''
* RESOURCE 3: ''[http://www.inp.net.pk/china-lauds-oics-resolution-on-xinjiang/ Organization of Islamic Cooperation investigation of Xinjiang (document 2)]''
* RESOURCE 4: [http://www.inp.net.pk/china-lauds-oics-resolution-on-xinjiang/ Egyptian media delegates visit Xinjiang]
==== Myth 6: "China is an imperialist country that wants to puppetize Africa"* ====
(TO BE STARTED)
==== Myth 7: "China commits cultural genocide in Tibet"* ====
(TO BE STARTED)
=== Cuba ===
==== Myth 1: "Che was a bloodthirsty butcher" ====
* RESOURCE 1: ''[http://gen.lib.rus.ec/book/index.php?md5=3E3E1D3A68BF27293A12BC1076076C7B Che: A Revolutionary Life]'' by Jon Lee Anderson
* RESOURCE 2: ''[https://anti-imperialism.org/2014/02/05/debunking-the-che-guevara-was-racist-lie/ Debunking the 'Che Guevara Was Racist!' Lie]'' by Cuervo Rojo
==== Myth 2: "Cuba is a dictatorship and a horrible place to live" ====
* RESOURCE 1: ''[https://www.invent-the-future.org/2013/07/20-reasons-to-support-cuba/ 20 Reasons to Support Cuba]''
* RESOURCE 2: ''[https://www.amazon.com/Cuba-Revolution-Motion-Isaac-Saney/dp/1842773631 Cuba: A Revolution in Motion]'' by Isaac Saney
* RESOURCE 3: ''[http://gen.lib.rus.ec/book/index.php?md5=79273783e814b6a8747ea24710d15f0c Cuba and Its Neighbours: Democracy in Motion]'' by Arnold August + https://www.democracyintheus.com/
* RESOURCE 4: ''[https://www.cuba-solidarity.org.uk/resources/democracyfactsheet2015.pdf Cuban Democracy Fact Sheet]''
* RESOURCE 5: ''[https://www.cuba-solidarity.org.uk/cubasi/article/187/all-in-this-together-cubarsquos-participatory-democracy All in This Together: Cuba's Participatory Democracy]''
* RESOURCE 6: ''[https://dissidentvoice.org/2010/05/the-elected-delegate-and-the-dissident-in-cuba%E2%80%99s-municipal-elections/ The Elected Delegate and the Dissident in Cuba's Municipal Elections]'' by Arnold August
* RESOURCE 7: ''[https://www.walterlippmann.com/cubanconstitution.html 2002 Cuban Constitution]''
* RESOURCE 8: ''[http://gen.lib.rus.ec/book/index.php?md5=fdfc7aee98499baaae696d5b1e04c065 Work and Democracy in Socialist Cuba]'' by Linda Fuller
=== Albania ===


=== General anti-communist myths ===
==== Myth 1: "Albania was a totalitarian dictatorship" ====
 
* RESOURCE 1: ''[http://gen.lib.rus.ec/book/index.php?md5=ad84f6afb71fc78856edd02dcec65c7f Pickaxe and Rifle: The Story of the Albanian People]'' by William Ash
* RESOURCE 2: ''[https://revolutionaryspiritapl.blogspot.com/2011/03/insights-into-socialist-albania-from.html Insights into Socialist Albania from 'Pickaxe and Rifle']''
=== DPRK* ===
 
==== Myth 1: "North Koreans believe in unicorns and that Kim-Jong-Un is immortal and that the DPRK is the entire world" ====
 
* RESOURCE 1: ''[https://anti-imperialism.org/2014/08/14/western-dprk-propaganda-the-worst-occasionally-hilarious-and-often-racist-lies/ Western DPRK Propaganda: The Worst, Occasionally Hilarious, and Often Racist, Lies]'' by Alyx Mayer
* RESOURCE 2: ''[https://redyouthuk.wordpress.com/2014/08/01/dprk-propaganda-war-a-cavalcade-of-comedy/ Anti-DPRK Propaganda War – a Cavalcade of Comedy]'' by Red Youth
* RESOURCE 3: ''[https://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-2638213/Tourist-took-camera-inside-North-Korea-expected-really-really-sad-people-shocked-seemingly-ordinary-lives-citizens.html Tourist who took camera inside North Korea shocked by 'ordinary'] lives of citizens''
* RESOURCE 4: [https://www.liberationnews.org/my-trip-to-north-korea-13-misconceptions-corrected/ ''My trip to North Korea: 13 misconceptions corrected'']
* RESOURCE 5: [https://medium.com/defiant/a-lot-of-what-you-know-about-north-korea-is-racist-nonsense-a625256b51cc ''A Lot Of What You Know About North Korea Is Racist Nonsense'']
* RESOURCE 6: [https://www.theguardian.com/world/2014/nov/20/-sp-north-korea-matthew-miller ''Freed American Matthew Miller: ‘I wanted to stay in North Korea’'']
* RESOURCE 7: [https://greekreporter.com/2017/10/14/exclusive-the-greek-who-lived-in-north-korea-tells-her-story/ ''Exclusive: The Greek Who Lived in North Korea Tells Her Story'']
* RESOURCE 8: [https://www.mintpressnews.com/north-korea-neither-trump-nor-western-media-wants-world-see/233355/ ''The North Korea Neither Trump Nor Western Media Wants the World to See'']
 
==== Myth 2: "The DPRK is a fascist monarchy" ====
 
* RESOURCE 1: ''[https://return2source.wordpress.com/2012/01/17/korea-resilient-socialism-in-democratic-korea/ Korea Resilient! Socialism in Democratic Korea]'' by Vince Sherman
* RESOURCE 2: ''[https://mltoday.com/article/1302-how-to-think-about-socialism-in-korea/ How to Think about Socialism in Korea]''
* RESOURCE 3: ''[https://www.kfausa.org/dprk-constitution/ Constitution of the DPRK]''
* RESOURCE 4: ''[http://gen.lib.rus.ec/book/index.php?md5=6b0447bc14808161362b828aee0a284a Socialist Korea: A Case Study in the Strategy of Economic Development]'' by Brun and Hersch
* RESOURCE 5: ''[https://archive.is/aMJCI Democracy: US vs DPRK – Towards the Annihilation of a Narrative]''
* RESOURCE 6: [https://www.exutopia.com/on-smoking-weed-in-north-korea/ ''On Smoking Weed in North Korea'']
* RESOURCE 7: [https://www.theguardian.com/world/2014/may/20/north-korea-unlikely-champion-fight-against-climate-change ''North Korea: an unlikely champion in the fight against climate change'']
* RESOURCE 8: [https://www.rt.com/news/416572-north-korea-executed-kim-return/ ''Zombie Nation? ‘Executed’ North Koreans return to life'']
* RESOURCE 9: [https://theduran.com/truth-north-korea-booming/ ''The truth about North Korea: it’s booming'']
 
==== Myth 3: "Kim Jong Un is a lunatic who wants to nuke the world" ====
 
* RESOURCE 1: [https://invent-the-future.org/2013/11/understanding-north-korea/ ''Interview: Understanding and Defending North Korea''] - Very insightful must read interview with Yongho Thae, Minister of the DPRK embassy in London.
* RESOURCE 2: [https://journal-neo.org/2016/03/18/north-korea-punished-for-helping-to-liberate-africa/ ''North Korea Punished for Helping to Liberate Africa'']
* RESOURCE 3: [https://www.theguardian.com/world/2014/jun/19/black-panthers-north-korea-us-imperialism ''How Black Panthers turned to North Korea in fight against US imperialism'']
* RESOURCE 4: [https://journal-neo.org/2017/03/13/north-korea-the-grand-deception-revealed/ ''North Korea: The Grand Deception Revealed'']
* RESOURCE 5: [https://www.theguardian.com/world/2016/may/08/north-korea-will-only-use-nuclear-weapons-if-sovereignty-is-threatened ''North Korea will not use nuclear weapons first, says Kim Jong-un'']
* RESOURCE 6: [https://gowans.blog/2017/07/05/the-real-reason-washington-is-worried-about-north-koreas-icbm-test/ ''The Real Reason Washington is Worried about North Korea’s ICBM Test'']
* RESOURCE 7: [https://journal-neo.org/2014/11/30/north-korea-the-un-and-war-propaganda-2/ ''North Korea, The UN, And War Propaganda'']
 
==== Myth 4: "People who leave North Korea think they've reached heaven and that the DPRK is a shithole which tortured them" ====
 
* RESOURCE 1: [https://www.sbs.com.au/news/north-korean-defector-confesses-to-murder-report/ea2a2c62-8b18-4f76-9bb8-49be15d8a000 ''North Korean defector confesses to murder'']
* RESOURCE 2: [https://www.nknews.org/2017/10/former-defector-back-in-north-korea-describes-painful-life-in-the-south/ ''Former defector back in North Korea describes ”painful” life in the South'']
* RESOURCE 3: [https://www.nknews.org/2017/09/why-two-north-korean-defectors-want-to-go-back/ ''Why two North Korean defectors want to go back'']
* RESOURCE 4: [https://www.bbc.com/news/world-asia-39170614 ''South Korea boosts reward for defectors from North to $860,000'']
* RESOURCE 5: [https://www.theguardian.com/world/2015/oct/13/why-do-north-korean-defector-testimonies-so-often-fall-apart ''Why do North Korean defector testimonies so often fall apart?'']
* RESOURCE 6: [https://www.dw.com/en/north-korea-defector-returns-home-calling-south-capitalist-hell/a-39745918 ''North Korean defector returns home calling South ‘capitalist hell’'']
* RESOURCE 7: [https://youtu.be/ktE_3PrJZO0 ''Loyal Citizens of Pyongyang in Seoul'']
* RESOURCE 8: [https://youtu.be/6YtTd31I15g ''Homegrown Outcasts: North Koreans in Japan'']
 
==== Myth 5: "The Korean War was started by the North"* ====
(TO BE STARTED)
 
=== General anti-communist myths* ===


==== Myth 1: "Socialism is an economic failure" ====
==== Myth 1: "Socialism is an economic failure" ====
Line 85: Line 204:
* RESOURCE 9: ''[https://www.counterpunch.org/2014/10/24/freest-under-czech-communism/ Freest Under Czech Communism!]''
* RESOURCE 9: ''[https://www.counterpunch.org/2014/10/24/freest-under-czech-communism/ Freest Under Czech Communism!]''
* RESOURCE 10: [https://gowans.wordpress.com/2013/12/23/seven-myths-about-the-ussr/ ''Seven Myths about the USSR'' by Stephen Gowans]
* RESOURCE 10: [https://gowans.wordpress.com/2013/12/23/seven-myths-about-the-ussr/ ''Seven Myths about the USSR'' by Stephen Gowans]
==== Myth 3: "Life under socialism is/was terrible"* ====
* RESOURCE 1: ''[https://drive.google.com/file/d/0B-eTgjCs2lzpMl92U3JzQ0pIa3c/view?usp=sharing An experiment in living socialism: Bulgaria then and now]'' by F.S.
* RESOURCE 2: ''[https://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-1221064/Oppressive-grey-No-growing-communism-happiest-time-life.html Growing Up Under Communism Was The Happiest Time Of My Life]'' by Zsuzsanna Clark
==== Myth 4: "There is no innovation under socialism"* ====
(TO BE STARTED)
== Other myths ==
=== Yugoslavia* ===
==== Myth 1: "Yugoslavia was a Serb-controlled state"* ====
(TO BE STARTED)
==== Myth 2: "Slobodan Milošević was a Serbian chauvinist and responsible for the dissolution of Yugoslavia"* ====
(TO BE STARTED)
==== Myth 3: "Milošević was responsible for the crimes in Bosnia"* ====
(TO BE STARTED)
==== Myth 4: "Milošević commited a genocide in Kosovo"* ====
(TO BE STARTED)
==== Myth 5: "Republika Srpska and the Republic of Serbian Krajina were Yugoslav puppet states"* ====
(TO BE STARTED)
==== Myth 6: "The KLA were legitimate freedom fighters"* ====
(TO BE STARTED)
=== Russia* ===
==== Myth 1: "Russia is an imperialist power"* ====
* RESOURCE 1: ''[https://mronline.org/2019/01/02/is-russia-imperialist/ Is Russia imperialist?]'' by Stransfield Smith
=== Russo-Ukrainian war ===
==== Myth 1: "Russia is the aggressor"* ====
(TO BE STARTED)
==== Myth 2: "Ukraine is not a nazi state"* ====
(TO BE STARTED)
=== "Israel" and Palestine* ===
==== Myth 1: "Israel is a democratic country"* ====
(TO BE STARTED)
==== Myth 2: "Hamas is an anti-Semite terrorist organization"* ====
(TO BE STARTED)
==== Myth 3: "Israeli attacks in Gazan civilian infrastructure are necessary to destroy Hamas and are not a genocide"* ====
(TO BE STARTED)
==== Myth 4: "Israel commits no genocide and isn't a settler-colonial state"* ====
(TO BE STARTED)
==== Myth 5: "Hamas has decapitated babies and raped women during the October 7 attacks"* ====
(TO BE STARTED)
==== Myth 6: "The Nakba is fabricated by Palestinian resistance organizations which use human shields to purposefully cause more deaths"* ====
(TO BE STARTED)
==== Myth 7: "Palestine is not real"* ====
(TO BE STARTED)
[[Category:Debunking myths]]

Latest revision as of 12:56, 27 January 2024

Here I'll cite sources to debunk common anti-communist and other myths. Of course, if I find more material, I'll add it here.

Titles with an asterisk are not finished.

Anti-communist myths

Soviet Union / Warsaw Pact*

Myth 1: "The Soviet Union manufactured a famine in Ukraine"

Myth 2: "The Soviet Union was a totalitarian dictatorship which killed millions of people"

Myth 3: "The Soviet Union and the Warsaw Pact were undemocratic"

Myth 4: "Lenin actually wanted to be succeeded in Trotsky, not Stalin"*

(TO BE STARTED)

Myth 5: "The Nazis and the Soviets were the same and were allies"*

(TO BE STARTED)

Myth 6: "Stalin was an anti-semite"*

(TO BE STARTED)

Myth 7: "Beria was a pedophile"*

(TO BE STARTED)

Myth 8: "The 1921-1922 famine was manufactured by the Soviet Union"*

(TO BE STARTED)

Myth 9: "The 1956 Hungarian Revolution was a democratic revolution against the communists and was brutally repressed by the Soviet Union"*

(TO BE STARTED)

Myth 10: "The Prague Spring was a democratic revolution against the communists and was brutally repressed by the Soviet Union"*

(TO BE STARTED)

Myth 11: "Stalin wanted a divided Germany"*

(TO BE STARTED)

Myth 12: "East Germany was a totalitarian dictatorship which killed everyone who tried to leave and was also poor"*

Myth 13: "Stalin wanted to control Yugoslavia"*

(TO BE STARTED)

People's Republic of China*

Myth 1: "Mao killed ~78 million people"

Myth 2: "China under Mao was a totalitarian dictatorship"

Myth 3: "China has reverted to capitalism"*

Myth 4: "China is a totalitarian dictatorship"*

Myth 5: "China commits a genocide against Uyghurs"*

Myth 6: "China is an imperialist country that wants to puppetize Africa"*

(TO BE STARTED)

Myth 7: "China commits cultural genocide in Tibet"*

(TO BE STARTED)

Cuba

Myth 1: "Che was a bloodthirsty butcher"

Myth 2: "Cuba is a dictatorship and a horrible place to live"

Albania

Myth 1: "Albania was a totalitarian dictatorship"

DPRK*

Myth 1: "North Koreans believe in unicorns and that Kim-Jong-Un is immortal and that the DPRK is the entire world"

Myth 2: "The DPRK is a fascist monarchy"

Myth 3: "Kim Jong Un is a lunatic who wants to nuke the world"

Myth 4: "People who leave North Korea think they've reached heaven and that the DPRK is a shithole which tortured them"

Myth 5: "The Korean War was started by the North"*

(TO BE STARTED)

General anti-communist myths*

Myth 1: "Socialism is an economic failure"

Myth 2: "Everybody hated socialism"

Myth 3: "Life under socialism is/was terrible"*

Myth 4: "There is no innovation under socialism"*

(TO BE STARTED)

Other myths

Yugoslavia*

Myth 1: "Yugoslavia was a Serb-controlled state"*

(TO BE STARTED)

Myth 2: "Slobodan Milošević was a Serbian chauvinist and responsible for the dissolution of Yugoslavia"*

(TO BE STARTED)

Myth 3: "Milošević was responsible for the crimes in Bosnia"*

(TO BE STARTED)

Myth 4: "Milošević commited a genocide in Kosovo"*

(TO BE STARTED)

Myth 5: "Republika Srpska and the Republic of Serbian Krajina were Yugoslav puppet states"*

(TO BE STARTED)

Myth 6: "The KLA were legitimate freedom fighters"*

(TO BE STARTED)

Russia*

Myth 1: "Russia is an imperialist power"*

Russo-Ukrainian war

Myth 1: "Russia is the aggressor"*

(TO BE STARTED)

Myth 2: "Ukraine is not a nazi state"*

(TO BE STARTED)

"Israel" and Palestine*

Myth 1: "Israel is a democratic country"*

(TO BE STARTED)

Myth 2: "Hamas is an anti-Semite terrorist organization"*

(TO BE STARTED)

Myth 3: "Israeli attacks in Gazan civilian infrastructure are necessary to destroy Hamas and are not a genocide"*

(TO BE STARTED)

Myth 4: "Israel commits no genocide and isn't a settler-colonial state"*

(TO BE STARTED)

Myth 5: "Hamas has decapitated babies and raped women during the October 7 attacks"*

(TO BE STARTED)

Myth 6: "The Nakba is fabricated by Palestinian resistance organizations which use human shields to purposefully cause more deaths"*

(TO BE STARTED)

Myth 7: "Palestine is not real"*

(TO BE STARTED)