Topic on ProleWiki:Hub

From ProleWiki, the proletarian encyclopedia

Comrade, because of your recent insistence on considering China a capitalist country, I will publish a critique of your "anti-revisionism" for what it is: pure and simply, metaphysical idealism. The text I will produce I will make public on Lemmygrad, and will publish it as an essay. I do not plan to make it a personal attack, I am engaging not with your personality, but with your ideas.

I should state, though, that your personality is sometimes "in the way" when you engage with others. You very commonly resort to name-calling (calling them "revisionists", "liberals", "anti-Marxists", etc.) and you do not engage with the idea of others, you simply attack them, calling their political understanding "Dengist Revisionist propaganda", and in general being usually hostile towards others in this position. I should remember you, in the last discussion we had about the Nazi sympathies of the Ukraine state and government, where you claimed I was "destroying our revolutionary ideals" through "text-book revisionism", when in fact you simply misinterpreted what I had said.

I've never seen so many people reacting negatively to comments from an account which ended up not getting banned, and I've been there for almost 3 years. This should say something, that the way you talk with others is not convincing, and that by being hostile to others, you're just making people hostile to your point, and shows you're extremely insecure in your position. But I will do the opposite of what you've been doing, and I will consider your points and produce a critique on the Essays section. Your capricious temperament will not be part of my criticism.