More languages
More actions
(Antisemitism) Tag: Visual edit |
No edit summary Tag: Visual edit |
||
| Line 1: | Line 1: | ||
{{Infobox | {{Infobox politician|name=George Orwell|birth_name=Eric Arthur Blair|birth_date=25 June 1903|death_date=21 January 1950|birth_place=Motihari, [[Presidency of Fort William (1699–1947)|Bengal Province]], [[British Raj (1858–1947)|British India]]|death_place=London, England, [[UK]]|political_orientation=[[Democratic socialism]] (claimed)<br>[[Anti-communism]]|image=George Orwell.png}} | ||
'''Eric Arthur Blair''' commonly known by his pen-name '''George Orwell''', was a prominent essayist and novelist, who called himself a '[[Democratic socialism|democratic socialist]]'. However, he was considered a [[Left-wing anticommunism|left wing anti-communist]] due to his [[Anti-communism|anti-communist]] views<ref>{{News citation|journalist=[[Rainer Shea]]|title=Orwell’s 1984 is a paranoid piece of anti-communist propaganda|url=https://www.greanvillepost.com/2020/01/21/orwells-1984-is-a-paranoid-piece-of-anti-communist-propaganda/|newspaper=[[Greanville Post]]}}</ref> which led him to even collude with imperial Britain<ref>https://www.independent.co.uk/news/orwells-little-list-leaves-the-left-gasping-for-more-1328633.html</ref> in stark contrast to the anti-authoritarian virtues he claimed to espouse. Orwell was a member of the Indian Imperial Police in British-occupied [[Burma]] and worked for the British propaganda outlet [[British Broadcasting Corporation|BBC]].<ref name=":0">{{News citation|author=[[Nikos Mottas]]|newspaper=[[In Defense of Communism]]|title=George Orwell, an anti-communist traitor|date=2022-07-18|url=http://www.idcommunism.com/2022/07/george-orwell-anti-communist-traitor.html|archive-url=https://web.archive.org/web/20220718030847/http://www.idcommunism.com/2022/07/george-orwell-anti-communist-traitor.html|archive-date=2022-07-18|retrieved=2022-07-18}}</ref> | '''Eric Arthur Blair''' commonly known by his pen-name '''George Orwell''', was a prominent essayist and novelist, who called himself a '[[Democratic socialism|democratic socialist]]'. However, he was considered a [[Left-wing anticommunism|left wing anti-communist]] due to his [[Anti-communism|anti-communist]] views<ref>{{News citation|journalist=[[Rainer Shea]]|title=Orwell’s 1984 is a paranoid piece of anti-communist propaganda|url=https://www.greanvillepost.com/2020/01/21/orwells-1984-is-a-paranoid-piece-of-anti-communist-propaganda/|newspaper=[[Greanville Post]]}}</ref> which led him to even collude with imperial Britain<ref>https://www.independent.co.uk/news/orwells-little-list-leaves-the-left-gasping-for-more-1328633.html</ref> in stark contrast to the anti-authoritarian virtues he claimed to espouse. Orwell was a member of the Indian Imperial Police in British-occupied [[Burma]] and worked for the British propaganda outlet [[British Broadcasting Corporation|BBC]].<ref name=":0">{{News citation|author=[[Nikos Mottas]]|newspaper=[[In Defense of Communism]]|title=George Orwell, an anti-communist traitor|date=2022-07-18|url=http://www.idcommunism.com/2022/07/george-orwell-anti-communist-traitor.html|archive-url=https://web.archive.org/web/20220718030847/http://www.idcommunism.com/2022/07/george-orwell-anti-communist-traitor.html|archive-date=2022-07-18|retrieved=2022-07-18}}</ref> | ||
| Line 9: | Line 9: | ||
=== ''Animal Farm'' === | === ''Animal Farm'' === | ||
''Animal Farm'' is a 1945 novella that is meant to be an allegory for the founding of the [[Union of Soviet Socialist Republics (1922-1991)|Soviet Union]] and [[Stalin]]'s rise to power. In the story, a farm of animals chase out their drunken owner and establish their own self-governing farm | ''Animal Farm'' is a 1945 novella that is meant to be an allegory for the founding of the [[Union of Soviet Socialist Republics (1922-1991)|Soviet Union]] and [[Stalin]]'s rise to power. In the story, a farm of animals chase out their drunken owner and establish their own self-governing farm. The pigs represent the [[Vanguard party|party]], the humans are the [[bourgeoisie]], and the other farm animals are the [[proletariat]]: | ||
The novella has had a permanent place on the curriculum of British schools since publication. Many study guides have been written to "help" students come to the "right" conclusion; that of anti-communism. These study guides, written to be succinct enough that they can be regurgitated on-demand by students, whose aim is not to seriously study the book but simply pass exams, exist to misinform students on [[Marxism]] and the [[Russian revolution]].<ref>{{News citation|author=[[Joti Brar]]|newspaper=[[Stalin Society]]|title=Anti-Communist Propagandist, Champion of Trotskyism and State Informer|date=2016-07-12|url=https://stalinsociety.net/?p=279}}</ref> Recent studies have discovered that the 1954 animated film adaptation was funded by the CIA to popularize falsehoods about Stalin and the Soviet Union<ref>{{Web citation|newspaper=British Library|title=1954 film version of Animal Farm by Halas and Batchelor|url=https://www.bl.uk/collection-items/1954-film-version-of-animal-farm-by-halas-and-batchelor#:~:text=Animal%20Farm%20and%20the%20CIA&text=The%201954%20film%20version%20of,anti%2DSoviet%20Union%20propaganda%20strategy.|quote=The 1954 film version of Animal Farm was secretly funded by the American intelligence agency the CIA, who bought the rights from the writer’s widow, Sonia Orwell. The film was commissioned as part of their anti-Stalin and anti-Soviet Union propaganda strategy.}}</ref> | * Mr. Jones: [[Nicholas II|Nicholas Romanov]] | ||
* Old Major: [[Karl Marx]] | |||
* Snowball: [[Vladimir Lenin|Lenin]]/[[Leon Trotsky|Trotsky]] | |||
* Napoleon: [[Joseph Stalin]] | |||
* Squealer: [[Vyacheslav Molotov]] | |||
* Boxer: [[Alexei Stakhanov]]<ref name=":1">{{Web citation|author=[[Jones Manoel]]|newspaper=[[Red Sails]]|title=A Critical Read of ''Animal Farm''|date=A Critical Read of Animal Farm|url=https://redsails.org/jones-on-animal-farm/|archive-url=https://web.archive.org/web/20230719012018/https://redsails.org/jones-on-animal-farm/|archive-date=2023-07-19}}</ref> | |||
A small group of pigs to effectively take all the power, and one particularly narcissistic pig named Napoleon sends guard dogs after the other pigs, making himself the undisputed ruler of the farm and oppressing his fellow animals into eventually acting just like humans. However, the book mainly criticizes not the revolutionaries, but the working class as a whole. Most of the book is spent depicting the animals as dumb and incapable of reasoning.<ref name=":1" /> | |||
The book is an allegory for how Stalin supposedly led the Soviet Union to become a shadow of its former self—an authoritarian [[Capitalism|capitalist]] state just like its enemies—and to this day the book is one of the most famous and respected pieces of anti-communist fiction. This book helped solidify Orwell's identity as an anti-communist leftist, and is also arguably what gave significant rise to the "not real socialism" argument for [[Actually Existing Socialism|AES]]. | |||
The novella has had a permanent place on the curriculum of British schools since publication. Many study guides have been written to "help" students come to the "right" conclusion; that of anti-communism. These study guides, written to be succinct enough that they can be regurgitated on-demand by students, whose aim is not to seriously study the book but simply pass exams, exist to misinform students on [[Marxism]] and the [[Russian revolution of 1917|Russian revolution]].<ref>{{News citation|author=[[Joti Brar]]|newspaper=[[Stalin Society]]|title=Anti-Communist Propagandist, Champion of Trotskyism and State Informer|date=2016-07-12|url=https://stalinsociety.net/?p=279}}</ref> Recent studies have discovered that the 1954 animated film adaptation was entirely funded by the CIA to popularize falsehoods about Stalin and the Soviet Union.<ref>{{Web citation|newspaper=British Library|title=1954 film version of Animal Farm by Halas and Batchelor|url=https://www.bl.uk/collection-items/1954-film-version-of-animal-farm-by-halas-and-batchelor#:~:text=Animal%20Farm%20and%20the%20CIA&text=The%201954%20film%20version%20of,anti%2DSoviet%20Union%20propaganda%20strategy.|quote=The 1954 film version of Animal Farm was secretly funded by the American intelligence agency the CIA, who bought the rights from the writer’s widow, Sonia Orwell. The film was commissioned as part of their anti-Stalin and anti-Soviet Union propaganda strategy.}}</ref> Between 1952 and 1957, the CIA sent millions of balloons carrying copies of ''Animal Farm'' into [[Czechoslovak Socialist Republic (1948–1990)|Czechoslovakia]], [[Hungarian People's Republic (1949–1989)|Hungary]], and [[Polish People's Republic (1947–1989)|Poland]].<ref name=":2">{{Web citation|author=Roderic Day|newspaper=[[Red Sails]]|title=On Orwell|date=2020-11-24|url=https://redsails.org/on-orwell/|archive-url=https://web.archive.org/web/20230722205825/https://redsails.org/on-orwell/|archive-date=2023-07-22|retrieved=}}</ref> | |||
=== ''1984'' === | === ''1984'' === | ||
1984 is a novel set in a dystopian | ''1984'' is a novel set in a dystopian version of the United Kingdom (referred to as Airstrip One). The novel is a thinly veiled panegyric to the plight of [[Leon Trotsky|Trotsky]], who is represented in the novel by the character Emmanuel Goldstein. He is reviled by the ruling Ingsoc Party, which is supposed to be an allegory to [[Marxism-leninism|Stalinism]]. ''1984'' is influential in political spheres due to concepts such as ''[[Newspeak]]'' (phrases such as ''wrongthink'' are often used by the [[far-right]] today) as well as the popularization of the ideas of Big Brother ([[totalitarianism]]) and mass surveillance. After Orwell's death, the [[Central Intelligence Agency|CIA]] created a government-funded film adaptation of the novel.<ref name=":0" /> | ||
1984 also may have represented English fear of an [[Republic of Ireland|Irish]] uprising. The main antagonist is named O'Brien, and Oceania's clocks use the Catholic 24-hour system.<ref name=":2" /> | |||
== Criticism == | == Criticism == | ||
Orwell's allegorical criticisms of the Soviet Union were published during the Second World War, thereby providing propaganda against the USSR at a time where many socialists were defending it in the fight against [[fascism]]. In his review of ''[[Mein Kampf]]'', released during the [[Second World War]], Orwell admitted that he did not dislike [[Adolf Hitler|Hitler]].<ref name=": | Orwell's allegorical criticisms of the Soviet Union were published during the Second World War, thereby providing propaganda against the USSR at a time where many socialists were defending it in the fight against [[fascism]]. | ||
=== Fascist sympathies === | |||
In his review of ''[[Mein Kampf]]'', released during the [[Second World War]], Orwell admitted that he did not dislike [[Adolf Hitler|Hitler]] and felt that Hitler, "can't win, and yet that he somehow deserves to."<ref name=":2" /> | |||
=== Orwell's list === | === Orwell's list === | ||
Despite his claimed anti-authoritarian virtues, Orwell composed lists of personalities noted to be sympathetic to the [[Union of Soviet Socialist Republics (1922–1991)|Soviet Union]].<ref>https://www.revolutionarydemocracy.org/rdv4n1/orwell.htm</ref> This list was given to the British government and remained a secret until 1996.<ref name=":0" /> The list was highly [[Antisemitism|antisemitic]] and [[Homophobia|homophobic]], with labels such as "[[Republic of Poland (1918–1939)|Polish]] [[Judaism|Jew]]" and "Jewess | Despite his claimed anti-authoritarian virtues, Orwell composed lists of personalities noted to be sympathetic to the [[Union of Soviet Socialist Republics (1922–1991)|Soviet Union]].<ref>https://www.revolutionarydemocracy.org/rdv4n1/orwell.htm</ref> This list was given to the British government and remained a secret until 1996.<ref name=":0" /> The list was highly [[Antisemitism|antisemitic]] and [[Homophobia|homophobic]], with labels such as "[[Republic of Poland (1918–1939)|Polish]] [[Judaism|Jew]]" and "Jewess" and labelled some non-Jewish people like [[Charlie Chaplin]] as suspected Jews.<ref>{{Web citation|author=Roderic Day|newspaper=[[Red Sails]]|title=Masses, Elites, and Rebels: The Theory of “Brainwashing”|date=2022-05-23|url=https://redsails.org/masses-elites-and-rebels/|archive-url=https://web.archive.org/web/20230811220826/https://redsails.org/masses-elites-and-rebels/|archive-date=2023-08-11}}</ref> It also described civil rights activists as "anti-white."<ref name=":2" /> | ||
=== Trotskyism === | === Trotskyism === | ||
Among Leninists it is commonly pointed out that Orwell was an unashamed supporter of [[Leon Trotsky]], and wholeheartedly believed in the idea that he was an innocent man wrongly persecuted by his fellow Bolsheviks. Being a democratic socialist, Orwell was obviously not a | Among Leninists it is commonly pointed out that Orwell was an unashamed supporter of [[Leon Trotsky]], and wholeheartedly believed in the idea that he was an innocent man wrongly persecuted by his fellow Bolsheviks. Being a democratic socialist, Orwell was obviously not a supporter of revolution in general, which explains his general disdain for vanguard movements as a whole, and why he favored the more decentralized nature of Revolutionary Catalonia. | ||
== References == | == References == | ||
<references /> | <references /> | ||
[[Category:The Compatible Left]] | |||
{{DEFAULTSORT:Orwell, George}} | |||
Revision as of 23:43, 16 September 2023
George Orwell | |
|---|---|
 | |
| Born | Eric Arthur Blair 25 June 1903 Motihari, Bengal Province, British India |
| Died | 21 January 1950 London, England, UK |
| Political orientation | Democratic socialism (claimed) Anti-communism |
Eric Arthur Blair commonly known by his pen-name George Orwell, was a prominent essayist and novelist, who called himself a 'democratic socialist'. However, he was considered a left wing anti-communist due to his anti-communist views[1] which led him to even collude with imperial Britain[2] in stark contrast to the anti-authoritarian virtues he claimed to espouse. Orwell was a member of the Indian Imperial Police in British-occupied Burma and worked for the British propaganda outlet BBC.[3]
Prominent works
Homage to Catalonia
Orwell's first real seminal work was the 1938 Homage to Catalonia, a memoir of his personal experience serving with the Trotskyist Workers' Party of Marxist Unification (POUM) in Revolutionary Catalonia during the Spanish Civil War.[3] Despite mostly an anarcho-communist region at the time, Orwell cites Revolutionary Catalonia as the basis for his hardline dedication to democratic socialism, as well as his self-proclaimed anti-authoritarianism. There is likely some ingenuousness in his words though, as the POUM was famously anti-Leninist and Orwell from this point forward dedicated most of his literary career to denouncing/"satirizing" Marxism-Leninism. It is to note that Orwell initially tried to get a trip to Spain through the Comintern-organised International Brigades. However, Harry Pollitt rejected him due to his lack of understanding party politics and lack of anti-fascist convictions.[4]
Animal Farm
Animal Farm is a 1945 novella that is meant to be an allegory for the founding of the Soviet Union and Stalin's rise to power. In the story, a farm of animals chase out their drunken owner and establish their own self-governing farm. The pigs represent the party, the humans are the bourgeoisie, and the other farm animals are the proletariat:
- Mr. Jones: Nicholas Romanov
- Old Major: Karl Marx
- Snowball: Lenin/Trotsky
- Napoleon: Joseph Stalin
- Squealer: Vyacheslav Molotov
- Boxer: Alexei Stakhanov[5]
A small group of pigs to effectively take all the power, and one particularly narcissistic pig named Napoleon sends guard dogs after the other pigs, making himself the undisputed ruler of the farm and oppressing his fellow animals into eventually acting just like humans. However, the book mainly criticizes not the revolutionaries, but the working class as a whole. Most of the book is spent depicting the animals as dumb and incapable of reasoning.[5]
The book is an allegory for how Stalin supposedly led the Soviet Union to become a shadow of its former self—an authoritarian capitalist state just like its enemies—and to this day the book is one of the most famous and respected pieces of anti-communist fiction. This book helped solidify Orwell's identity as an anti-communist leftist, and is also arguably what gave significant rise to the "not real socialism" argument for AES.
The novella has had a permanent place on the curriculum of British schools since publication. Many study guides have been written to "help" students come to the "right" conclusion; that of anti-communism. These study guides, written to be succinct enough that they can be regurgitated on-demand by students, whose aim is not to seriously study the book but simply pass exams, exist to misinform students on Marxism and the Russian revolution.[6] Recent studies have discovered that the 1954 animated film adaptation was entirely funded by the CIA to popularize falsehoods about Stalin and the Soviet Union.[7] Between 1952 and 1957, the CIA sent millions of balloons carrying copies of Animal Farm into Czechoslovakia, Hungary, and Poland.[8]
1984
1984 is a novel set in a dystopian version of the United Kingdom (referred to as Airstrip One). The novel is a thinly veiled panegyric to the plight of Trotsky, who is represented in the novel by the character Emmanuel Goldstein. He is reviled by the ruling Ingsoc Party, which is supposed to be an allegory to Stalinism. 1984 is influential in political spheres due to concepts such as Newspeak (phrases such as wrongthink are often used by the far-right today) as well as the popularization of the ideas of Big Brother (totalitarianism) and mass surveillance. After Orwell's death, the CIA created a government-funded film adaptation of the novel.[3]
1984 also may have represented English fear of an Irish uprising. The main antagonist is named O'Brien, and Oceania's clocks use the Catholic 24-hour system.[8]
Criticism
Orwell's allegorical criticisms of the Soviet Union were published during the Second World War, thereby providing propaganda against the USSR at a time where many socialists were defending it in the fight against fascism.
Fascist sympathies
In his review of Mein Kampf, released during the Second World War, Orwell admitted that he did not dislike Hitler and felt that Hitler, "can't win, and yet that he somehow deserves to."[8]
Orwell's list
Despite his claimed anti-authoritarian virtues, Orwell composed lists of personalities noted to be sympathetic to the Soviet Union.[9] This list was given to the British government and remained a secret until 1996.[3] The list was highly antisemitic and homophobic, with labels such as "Polish Jew" and "Jewess" and labelled some non-Jewish people like Charlie Chaplin as suspected Jews.[10] It also described civil rights activists as "anti-white."[8]
Trotskyism
Among Leninists it is commonly pointed out that Orwell was an unashamed supporter of Leon Trotsky, and wholeheartedly believed in the idea that he was an innocent man wrongly persecuted by his fellow Bolsheviks. Being a democratic socialist, Orwell was obviously not a supporter of revolution in general, which explains his general disdain for vanguard movements as a whole, and why he favored the more decentralized nature of Revolutionary Catalonia.
References
- ↑ Rainer Shea. "Orwell’s 1984 is a paranoid piece of anti-communist propaganda" Greanville Post.
- ↑ https://www.independent.co.uk/news/orwells-little-list-leaves-the-left-gasping-for-more-1328633.html
- ↑ 3.0 3.1 3.2 3.3 Nikos Mottas (2022-07-18). "George Orwell, an anti-communist traitor" In Defense of Communism. Archived from the original on 2022-07-18. Retrieved 2022-07-18.
- ↑ Bill Alexander (1984). George Orwell and Spain.
- ↑ 5.0 5.1 Jones Manoel (A Critical Read of Animal Farm). "A Critical Read of Animal Farm" Red Sails. Archived from the original on 2023-07-19.
- ↑ Joti Brar (2016-07-12). "Anti-Communist Propagandist, Champion of Trotskyism and State Informer" Stalin Society.
- ↑ “The 1954 film version of Animal Farm was secretly funded by the American intelligence agency the CIA, who bought the rights from the writer’s widow, Sonia Orwell. The film was commissioned as part of their anti-Stalin and anti-Soviet Union propaganda strategy.”
"1954 film version of Animal Farm by Halas and Batchelor". British Library. - ↑ 8.0 8.1 8.2 8.3 Roderic Day (2020-11-24). "On Orwell" Red Sails. Archived from the original on 2023-07-22.
- ↑ https://www.revolutionarydemocracy.org/rdv4n1/orwell.htm
- ↑ Roderic Day (2022-05-23). "Masses, Elites, and Rebels: The Theory of “Brainwashing”" Red Sails. Archived from the original on 2023-08-11.